Omnibus Directive price rules: the 30-day prior price when you announce a price cut in the EU
You run a sale or show a crossed-out price to EU shoppers and need to know which old price the law lets you use.
When you announce a price cut to EU consumers, show the lowest price you charged in at least the 30 days before it, and work any percentage off it. Countries set their own rules for new, perishable and stepped goods.
Any announcement of a price reduction must indicate the prior price applied by the trader, which is the lowest price the trader applied during a period of not less than 30 days before the reduction (Art. 6a(1)Directive 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)Article 6a, paragraph 1Click opens the article on EUR-Lex. and Art. 6a(2)Directive 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)Article 6a, paragraph 2Click opens the article on EUR-Lex. of Directive 98/6/EC, inserted by Art. 2Directive (EU) 2019/2161, Omnibus DirectiveArticle 2Click opens the article on EUR-Lex. of Directive (EU) 2019/2161). EU countries had to apply the rule from 28 May 2022 (Art. 7(1)Directive (EU) 2019/2161, Omnibus DirectiveArticle 7, paragraph 1Click opens the article on EUR-Lex. of Directive (EU) 2019/2161). The Commission notice of 29 December 2021 says Art. 6aDirective 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)Article 6aClick opens the article on EUR-Lex. applies to the seller of the goods, including a seller that uses an online marketplace and a seller outside the EU that directs its sales to EU consumers, and not to a marketplace that only provides the means to sell (Commission Notice 2021/C 526/02, section 1.2). The Court of Justice ruled on 26 September 2024 that a reduction announced as a percentage, or by a promotional statement that stresses the advantage of the price, must be determined on the basis of the prior price, so the reduced price cannot equal or exceed it (Case C-330/23, Aldi Süd, paragraphs 27 and 29 and the operative part). EU countries may set different rules for goods liable to deteriorate or expire rapidly, a shorter period for a product on the market for less than 30 days, and a prior price taken before the first step of a progressive reduction (Art. 6a(3)Directive 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)Article 6a, paragraph 3Click opens the article on EUR-Lex., Art. 6a(4)Directive 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)Article 6a, paragraph 4Click opens the article on EUR-Lex. and Art. 6a(5)Directive 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)Article 6a, paragraph 5Click opens the article on EUR-Lex. of Directive 98/6/EC). The same Directive requires the selling price, the final price including VAT and all other taxes, and the unit price per kilogramme, litre, metre, square metre or cubic metre, to be unambiguous, easily identifiable and clearly legible, and an EU country may waive the unit price where it would not be useful (Art. 2Directive 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)Article 2Click opens the article on EUR-Lex., Art. 3Directive 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)Article 3Click opens the article on EUR-Lex., Art. 4Directive 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)Article 4Click opens the article on EUR-Lex. and Art. 5Directive 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)Article 5Click opens the article on EUR-Lex. of Directive 98/6/EC). Penalties are national and must be effective, proportionate and dissuasive (Art. 8(1)Directive 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)Article 8, paragraph 1Click opens the article on EUR-Lex. of Directive 98/6/EC). Germany makes a missing or wrong lowest price an administrative offence with a fine of up to EUR 25,000, or up to EUR 12,500 for negligence, which may be exceeded to take away the gain from the breach (§ 11(1) and § 20 No. 1 of the Preisangabenverordnung; § 3(2) of the Wirtschaftsstrafgesetz 1954; § 17(2) and (4) of the Ordnungswidrigkeitengesetz). In the Netherlands Art. 5aDirective 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)Article 5aClick opens the article on EUR-Lex. of the Besluit prijsaanduiding producten has applied since 1 January 2023 and the consumer authority fined five web shops a total of EUR 621,000 for fake discounts in 2024 (Staatsblad 2022, 485, Article II; Netherlands, Authority for Consumers and Markets, fines of 11 June 2024). Italy sets the rule in Art. 17Directive 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)Article 17Click opens the article on EUR-Lex.-bis of the Codice del consumo (Art. 17Directive 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)Article 17Click opens the article on EUR-Lex.-bis of Decreto legislativo 6 settembre 2005, n. 206).
When you tell an EU consumer that a price has gone down, you must show the lowest price you charged in at least the 30 days before the reduction, and any percentage you advertise must be worked out from that price. This is the price-reduction rule that the Omnibus Directive added to the Price Indication Directive. It applies to a seller of goods outside the EU that directs its sales to EU consumers, in its own shop or on a marketplace. Countries add their own choices on perishable, new and stepped-down goods, and they set the fines. It is part of EU consumer law.
What you do:
- Before every announcement of a lower price, find the lowest price you charged for that product in the 30 days before. Count any earlier sale price in that period (Art. 6a(1)Directive 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)Article 6a, paragraph 1Click opens the article on EUR-Lex., Art. 6a(2)Directive 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)Article 6a, paragraph 2Click opens the article on EUR-Lex.; Commission Notice 2021/C 526/02, section 2.1).
- Show that price as the old price in the announcement, and work any “% off” from it. The new price must be lower than it (Case C-330/23, paragraph 27 and the operative part; Commission Notice 2021/C 526/02, section 2.1).
- For a general banner such as “20 % off everything”, show the old price on each product page or price tag. The banner does not need to carry it (Commission Notice 2021/C 526/02, section 2.2).
- Keep a dated price history for each product and each sales channel. The Directive does not prescribe a record, but you cannot name a lowest price you did not keep (Art. 6a(2)Directive 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)Article 6a, paragraph 2Click opens the article on EUR-Lex.).
- Show the selling price with VAT and all other taxes included, and next to it the unit price, unless the country you sell into has waived it for that product. The same goes for an advertisement that names the selling price (Art. 2(a)Directive 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)Article 2, point (a)Click opens the article on EUR-Lex., Art. 3(1)Directive 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)Article 3, paragraph 1Click opens the article on EUR-Lex., Art. 3(4)Directive 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)Article 3, paragraph 4Click opens the article on EUR-Lex., Art. 5Directive 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)Article 5Click opens the article on EUR-Lex.).
- For perishable goods, new products and prices that step down in stages, follow the national rule of each country you sell into. The Directive leaves these three choices to the countries (Art. 6a(3)Directive 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)Article 6a, paragraph 3Click opens the article on EUR-Lex., Art. 6a(4)Directive 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)Article 6a, paragraph 4Click opens the article on EUR-Lex., Art. 6a(5)Directive 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)Article 6a, paragraph 5Click opens the article on EUR-Lex.).
The rule covers any announcement that your price went down
Art. 6a applies to promotional statements that you have reduced the price you charge for goods (Commission Notice 2021/C 526/02, section 1.1). The Commission gives the forms. It also says that a statement such as a “sale” price, a “special offer” or a “Black Friday offer” is covered when it creates the impression of a price reduction, even if it shows no measurable reduction. The rule applies in shops and online alike (Commission Notice 2021/C 526/02, section 1.1).
| Your statement | Covered by Art. 6a | Where it is covered |
|---|---|---|
| “20 % off”, “EUR 10 off”, “now EUR 50, was EUR 100”, a crossed-out old price | Yes | Commission Notice 2021/C 526/02, section 1.1 |
| “Sale”, “special offer”, “Black Friday offer” that suggests a lower price | Yes | Commission Notice 2021/C 526/02, section 1.1 |
| “Buy today without paying the VAT” presented as a reduction of the VAT amount | Yes | Commission Notice 2021/C 526/02, section 1.1 |
| A code or “members only” weekend discount that many or most customers can use | Yes, because it is offered to consumers in general | Commission Notice 2021/C 526/02, section 2.3 |
| “Best price”, “lowest prices” and comparisons with other sellers or a recommended retail price | No. The Unfair Commercial Practices Directive still applies | Commission Notice 2021/C 526/02, sections 1.1 and 3 |
| Combined offers such as “buy one, get two” | No. The Unfair Commercial Practices Directive still applies | Commission Notice 2021/C 526/02, section 3 |
| A long-term loyalty card, or a voucher a customer earned by an earlier purchase | No. The Unfair Commercial Practices Directive still applies | Commission Notice 2021/C 526/02, section 2.3 |
The rule is for goods. The Commission reads “products” in the Directive as movable goods, so Art. 6a does not apply to services or to digital content (Commission Notice 2021/C 526/02, section 1.1). A price cut on a service or a download is judged under the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive (Commission Notice 2021/C 526/02, section 3).
Art. 6a does not stop you from changing prices. It deals with announcements of a reduction, not with price changes that are not announced (Commission Notice 2021/C 526/02, section 1.1).
The prior price is your own lowest price in at least the 30 days before the reduction
An announcement of a price reduction must indicate the prior price you applied for a determined period before the reduction. The prior price is the lowest price you applied during a period not shorter than 30 days before the reduction (Art. 6a(1)Directive 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)Article 6a, paragraph 1Click opens the article on EUR-Lex., Art. 6a(2)Directive 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)Article 6a, paragraph 2Click opens the article on EUR-Lex.). The Commission says the 30 days exist to stop traders raising a price for a short time and then presenting the fall as a large reduction. It confirms that the lowest price includes any earlier reduced price in that period (Commission Notice 2021/C 526/02, section 2.1).
An example, with invented numbers. A product costs EUR 100 for 40 days. For the next 10 days it is EUR 80. It then goes back to EUR 100.
| When you announce a new reduction | Lowest price in the 30 days before | Old price you may show |
|---|---|---|
| 10 days after the EUR 80 sale ended | EUR 80, the earlier sale price | EUR 80. A “30 % off” announcement means 30 % off EUR 80, which is EUR 56. |
| 35 days after the EUR 80 sale ended | EUR 100 | EUR 100 |
Four points from the Commission notice:
- You may show a longer period than 30 days, and a lower price from further back, because that is not contrary to Art. 6a. A national rule that demands a period longer than 30 days has to be tested against EU law (Commission Notice 2021/C 526/02, section 2.1; Art. 10Directive 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)Article 10Click opens the article on EUR-Lex.).
- You do not have to say how long you applied the old price. A reduction campaign may last longer than 30 days. The old price stays the lowest price of the 30 days before the campaign began (Commission Notice 2021/C 526/02, section 2.1).
- You may show other reference prices, such as your usual price outside sales, if each is clearly explained and none hides the old price (Commission Notice 2021/C 526/02, section 2.1).
- A “starting price” with a higher price to come changes nothing. If you apply the higher price for under 30 days and then announce a reduction, the old price is still the lowest price of the last 30 days, which is the starting price (Commission Notice 2021/C 526/02, section 2.1).
A percentage must be worked out from the prior price, and the new price must be below it
Showing the prior price next to an advertised reduction is not enough if the reduction is calculated on another price. In the Aldi Süd case a German brochure showed bananas at EUR 1.29, a struck-through EUR 1.69 and the text “Lowest price in the last 30 days” beside a third price. The Court of Justice ruled on that a reduction announced as a percentage, or by a promotional statement that stresses the advantage of the price, must be determined on the basis of the prior price (Case C-330/23, paragraphs 11 and 29 and the operative part). It added that the selling price presented as reduced cannot be the same as the prior price or higher than it (Case C-330/23, paragraph 27).
The Court gave the reason. If a seller only had to mention the prior price, it could still calculate the reduction from a higher price and mislead the buyer (Case C-330/23, paragraphs 24 and 26). The Commission notice gives a matching example: for “50 % off” with a lowest price of EUR 100 in the last 30 days, you present EUR 100 as the old price, even if your last selling price was EUR 160 (Commission Notice 2021/C 526/02, section 2.1).
A banner for the whole shop is allowed, with the old price at the product
You may announce a general reduction such as “20 % off everything today”. The old price does not have to appear in the banner. It must appear at the point of sale, which online means the price section of each product page (Commission Notice 2021/C 526/02, section 2.2). Two cases:
- You did not change the price of the product or run another general reduction in the last 30 days. The price already shown is the old price and nothing needs to change.
- You raised the price, or ran another general reduction, in the last 30 days. The price shown is no longer the lowest of the 30 days, so you change the old price on each product concerned (Commission Notice 2021/C 526/02, section 2.2).
If you give different discounts to different categories of goods, you identify the categories and each discount. A shop-wide campaign that a franchisor or another central entity announces for you does not take the duty away. Each seller is still responsible for the old price of the goods it sells (Commission Notice 2021/C 526/02, section 2.2).
On a marketplace or in your own shop, the seller carries the duty
The Price Indication Directive applies to the trader, meaning anyone who sells or offers for sale products in the course of a commercial or professional activity (Art. 2(d)Directive 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)Article 2, point (d)Click opens the article on EUR-Lex.). The Commission says Art. 6a therefore applies to the seller that is party to the contract with the consumer, including a seller that uses an online marketplace. It does not apply to an intermediary that only provides the means to sell, such as a marketplace, or to a price comparison site. It does apply to the marketplace when it is the actual seller or sells for another trader (Commission Notice 2021/C 526/02, section 1.2).
For a seller outside the EU the Commission points to the Rome II Regulation. The law applicable to an act of unfair competition is the law of the country where the collective interests of consumers are, or are likely to be, affected, and an agreement cannot change that. The Commission concludes that Art. 6a applies to traders based outside the EU that direct their sales to EU consumers, including through platforms (Commission Notice 2021/C 526/02, section 1.2; Art. 6(1) and Art. 6(4) of Regulation (EC) No 864/2007). The notice says the Price Indication Directive as a whole becomes applicable in that case, so the selling price and unit price rules reach such a seller too (Commission Notice 2021/C 526/02, section 1.2). Whether you direct your sales to a country is tested on EU consumer law.
If you sell the same goods in several channels, such as your own shop and two marketplaces, at different prices, and you make a general reduction announcement across them, the old price for each channel is the lowest price you applied in that channel in the last 30 days (Commission Notice 2021/C 526/02, section 2.1). An announcement that suggests all channels are reduced when only some are is judged under the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive (Commission Notice 2021/C 526/02, section 2.1).
Countries choose how to treat perishable, new and stepped-down goods
The Directive leaves three choices to each country. A country may set different rules for goods liable to deteriorate or expire rapidly, a shorter period for a product on the market for under 30 days, and a prior price taken before the first step when a reduction is progressively increased (Art. 6a(3)Directive 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)Article 6a, paragraph 3Click opens the article on EUR-Lex., Art. 6a(4)Directive 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)Article 6a, paragraph 4Click opens the article on EUR-Lex., Art. 6a(5)Directive 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)Article 6a, paragraph 5Click opens the article on EUR-Lex.). A country may not shorten the 30 days for other goods (Commission Notice 2021/C 526/02, section 2.1).
Where a country uses these choices, they work like this:
- Perishable goods are goods that spoil or expire rapidly, such as fresh food. Seasonal clothes are not, because they only expire in the commercial sense (Commission Notice 2021/C 526/02, section 4.1).
- A product counts as new only for the seller that sells it. A product you offer again after a break, or a seasonal product that returns, is not new. For such a product you can take a longer reference period in which you offered it for at least 30 days in total, and use the lowest price in that whole period (Commission Notice 2021/C 526/02, section 4.2).
- Step-down prices only keep the old price of the first step while the reduction rises without interruption. Successive campaigns inside 30 days, such as “20 % off every Sunday in December”, follow the general rule (Commission Notice 2021/C 526/02, section 4.3).
How three countries used the choices, from their texts:
| Country and rule | Perishable goods | New products (under 30 days) | Progressive reductions |
|---|---|---|---|
| Germany, § 11 PAngV | Exempt where the price is cut because spoilage or expiry is near and consumers are told in a suitable way (§ 11(4) No. 2). Individual price reductions are also exempt (§ 11(4) No. 1). | No separate rule in § 11. | The prior price from before the first step may be shown while the reduction rises without interruption (§ 11(2)). |
| Netherlands, Art. 5a of the Besluit prijsaanduiding producten, in force 1 January 2023 | For product categories a ministerial regulation names, the price applied right before the reduction may be shown (Art. 5a(2)). | The seller may show the lowest price in a period it states (Art. 5a(4)). The explanatory note limits this to 30 days after the product first went on sale. | For up to three calendar months after the first reduction, the lowest price of the 30 days before the first reduction may be shown (Art. 5a(3)). |
| Italy, Art. 17-bis of the Codice del consumo | Perishable agricultural and food products of Decreto legislativo 198/2021 are outside the 30-day rule (Art. 17-bis(3)). | The seller states the period the prior price refers to. Launch prices that rise in later announcements are outside the rule (Art. 17-bis(4)). | The 30-day rule applies to the first reduction of an uninterrupted campaign. Later reductions use the price before the first one (Art. 17-bis(5)). |
The table covers Germany, the Netherlands and Italy; every other EU country decides on the same three choices in its own law. The Commission notice says the Consumer Law Database on the e-Justice portal holds the national provisions that transpose the Directive (Commission Notice 2021/C 526/02, introduction).
The unit price is the price per kilogramme, litre, metre or square metre
The Directive requires the selling price and the unit price for the products it covers. The selling price is the final price for a unit or a given quantity, including VAT and all other taxes. The unit price is the final price including VAT and all other taxes for one kilogramme, one litre, one metre, one square metre, one cubic metre, or another single unit that is widely and customarily used in the country for that product (Art. 2(a)Directive 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)Article 2, point (a)Click opens the article on EUR-Lex., Art. 2(b)Directive 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)Article 2, point (b)Click opens the article on EUR-Lex., Art. 3(1)Directive 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)Article 3, paragraph 1Click opens the article on EUR-Lex.). The unit price need not be shown if it equals the selling price. For goods sold in bulk, which are not pre-packaged and are measured in front of the consumer, only the unit price is shown (Art. 2(c)Directive 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)Article 2, point (c)Click opens the article on EUR-Lex., Art. 3(1)Directive 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)Article 3, paragraph 1Click opens the article on EUR-Lex., Art. 3(3)Directive 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)Article 3, paragraph 3Click opens the article on EUR-Lex.). An advertisement that names a selling price also names the unit price (Art. 3(4)Directive 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)Article 3, paragraph 4Click opens the article on EUR-Lex.).
Both prices must be unambiguous, easily identifiable and clearly legible, and the unit price refers to the quantity declared under national and EU provisions (Art. 4(1)Directive 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)Article 4, paragraph 1Click opens the article on EUR-Lex., Art. 4(2)Directive 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)Article 4, paragraph 2Click opens the article on EUR-Lex.). For VAT, see EU VAT for online sellers.
A price reduction on a bulk good is announced on the unit price, and the old price is then the prior unit price (Commission Notice 2021/C 526/02, section 1.1).
A country may waive the unit price for products where it would not be useful because of their nature or purpose, or would confuse, and for non-food products it may list the categories where the unit price stays required. A country may also, for a transitional period, relieve certain small retail businesses of the unit price where it would be an excessive burden, and it may limit the number of prices shown (Art. 4(1)Directive 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)Article 4, paragraph 1Click opens the article on EUR-Lex., Art. 5Directive 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)Article 5Click opens the article on EUR-Lex., Art. 6Directive 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)Article 6Click opens the article on EUR-Lex.). Germany lists exceptions in § 4(3) PAngV. They include goods under 10 grams or 10 millilitres, goods that combine different products that are not mixed, cosmetics used only to colour or beautify skin, hair or nails, and perfumes with at least 3 % by volume of fragrance oil and at least 70 % by volume of pure ethyl alcohol. The waivers are national: each country you sell into has its own list.
Each country sets its own penalty
Each country lays down penalties for breaches of its national provisions under the Directive. They must be effective, proportionate and dissuasive, and the country takes into account factors such as the nature, gravity, scale and duration of the breach, any earlier breach and the gain the trader made (Art. 8(1)Directive 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)Article 8, paragraph 1Click opens the article on EUR-Lex., Art. 8(2)Directive 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)Article 8, paragraph 2Click opens the article on EUR-Lex.). The Directive names no turnover-based maximum for a breach of Art. 6a. The turnover maximum of at least 4 % of annual turnover that the Omnibus Directive set applies to the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive, in coordinated actions under the Consumer Protection Cooperation Regulation (Art. 13(3)Directive 2005/29/EC, Unfair Commercial Practices Directive (consolidated text of 27 September 2026)Article 13, paragraph 3Click opens the article on EUR-Lex.). The Price Indication Directive is on the list of acts that Regulation covers (Annex, point 2, of Regulation (EU) 2017/2394).
The two directives work together. Art. 6a is the specific rule on announcing a price reduction, and a specific rule takes precedence over the general one on the points it covers (Art. 3(4)Directive 2005/29/EC, Unfair Commercial Practices Directive (consolidated text of 27 September 2026)Article 3, paragraph 4Click opens the article on EUR-Lex.). In Aldi Süd the Court of Justice held that a reduction not determined on the prior price is assessed under Art. 6a and not under the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive (Case C-330/23, paragraph 28). The Unfair Commercial Practices Directive still governs what Art. 6a does not cover. The Commission names excessively long reduction periods, “up to 70 % off” when only a few items are reduced that much, and comparisons with a recommended retail price as practices that stay under that Directive (Art. 6(1)(d)Directive 2005/29/EC, Unfair Commercial Practices Directive (consolidated text of 27 September 2026)Article 6, paragraph 1, point (d)Click opens the article on EUR-Lex.; Commission Notice 2021/C 526/02, section 3).
Three examples:
| Country | Rule | What it says |
|---|---|---|
| Germany | § 11(1) PAngV; § 20 No. 1 PAngV; § 3(2) of the Wirtschaftsstrafgesetz 1954; § 17 of the Ordnungswidrigkeitengesetz | A person who must show a total price must show, for each reduction announced to consumers, the lowest total price applied in the last 30 days. Intentionally or negligently failing to show it correctly is an administrative offence, which may be fined up to EUR 25,000, or up to EUR 12,500 for negligence (§ 17(2) OWiG). The fine may go above the maximum where that is needed to exceed the gain from the breach (§ 17(4) OWiG). |
| Netherlands | Art. 5a of the Besluit prijsaanduiding producten; supervision by the Authority for Consumers and Markets (ACM) | In June 2024 the ACM fined five web shops a total of EUR 621,000 for fake discounts: EUR 163,000 for Day Traders (Koopjedeal), EUR 130,000 for Leen Bakker, EUR 110,000 for G-Star, EUR 112,500 for JYSK and EUR 105,500 for Tommy Hilfiger. The three that admitted the breach were fined less. On 11 November 2025 the Rotterdam court confirmed the fines on Leen Bakker and Koopjedeal, and the ACM says those rulings are final. |
| Italy | Art. 17-bis(7) of the Codice del consumo | A breach is punished with the administrative fine of Art. 22(3) of Decreto legislativo 114/1998, set with the criteria the Directive lists. Art. 22(3) gives a range of 1,000,000 to 6,000,000 lire, which is EUR 516.46 to EUR 3,098.74 at the fixed euro rate. |
The ACM gave two examples of what it fined. One shop showed a product “from” 699 and “for” 629 when the product had cost 539 in an earlier sale during the 30 days before. The other raised the “from” price of a product from 149.99 to 199.99 in one day, a price that was never charged.
What happens if you do nothing
An old price that is not the lowest price of the last 30 days is a breach of Art. 6a. The Court of Justice assesses such a practice under Art. 6a and not under the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive (Case C-330/23, paragraph 28). The authority of the country where your customers are can fine you under its national rule. In Germany that is an offence with a fine of up to EUR 25,000, or up to EUR 12,500 for negligence, and the fine may be set above the maximum to exceed the gain from the breach. In the Netherlands the ACM has fined web shops between EUR 105,500 and EUR 163,000 each (§ 3(2) of the Wirtschaftsstrafgesetz 1954; § 17(2) and (4) of the Ordnungswidrigkeitengesetz; Netherlands, ACM, fines of 11 June 2024).
A fine is not the only route. In Germany a consumers association can sue for an injunction against a misleading price reduction, as one did against Aldi Süd in the case that reached the Court of Justice (Case C-330/23, paragraph 14).
Authorities can also act against a seller outside the EU. Under Regulation (EU) 2017/2394 each authority must have the power, where no other effective means are available to stop the breach, to remove content or restrict access to an online interface, to order a hosting provider to disable an online interface, and to order a domain registry to delete a domain name. It must also be able to impose fines (Art. 9(4)(g) and (h) of Regulation (EU) 2017/2394; Commission Notice 2021/C 526/02, section 1.2).
What the law leaves open
- Who answers when a marketplace tool shows the struck-through price. The Commission notice puts the duty on the seller and keeps the marketplace out unless it sells. It does not discuss a marketplace tool or program that generates the old price, and neither does the Directive. No official source settles who answers in that case.
- What the notice is worth. It says it is guidance and that only the text of the legislation has legal force. In Case C-330/23 the Court of Justice reached the same reading of the prior price and quoted the notice and cited it for the aim of Art. 6a (paragraphs 9 and 25).
- The other countries’ choices. This page sets out the choices of Germany, the Netherlands and Italy only. The notice says the Consumer Law Database on the e-Justice portal holds the national provisions, case law and legal literature.
- Later amendments. The consolidated text of 28 May 2022 is the latest consolidation of Directive 98/6/ECDirective 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)The whole regulationClick opens the law on the EU Publications Office.. Its list of amending acts names only Directive (EU) 2019/2161Directive (EU) 2019/2161, Omnibus DirectiveThe whole regulationClick opens the law on the EU Publications Office., so the Directive has not been amended since that Directive inserted Art. 6a.
What you can skip
Sources
17 sources
- Art. 1 to 6, Art. 6aDirective 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)Article 6aClick opens the article on EUR-Lex., Art. 8Directive 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)Article 8Click opens the article on EUR-Lex., Art. 10Directive 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)Article 10Click opens the article on EUR-Lex.Directive 98/6/EC (Price Indication Directive), consolidated text of 28 May 2022 - purpose, definitions of selling price and unit price, indication of both, legibility, waivers of the unit price, Art. 6a on price reductions, penalties, more favourable national rules. Read 2026-10-05
- Art. 2Directive (EU) 2019/2161, Omnibus DirectiveArticle 2Click opens the article on EUR-Lex., Art. 3(6)Directive (EU) 2019/2161, Omnibus DirectiveArticle 3, paragraph 6Click opens the article on EUR-Lex., Art. 7(1)Directive (EU) 2019/2161, Omnibus DirectiveArticle 7, paragraph 1Click opens the article on EUR-Lex.Directive (EU) 2019/2161 (Omnibus Directive), Official Journal text of 18 December 2019 - Art. 2 inserts Art. 6a and replaces Art. 8 of Directive 98/6/EC; Art. 3 replaces Art. 13 of Directive 2005/29/EC; Art. 7 sets the application date of 28 May 2022. Read 2026-10-05
- Commission statement, not law; sections 1 to 4Commission Notice 2021/C 526/02 - Guidance on the interpretation and application of Article 6a of Directive 98/6/EC, Official Journal C 526 of 29 December 2021. A guidance document: only the text of the Union legislation has legal force. Read 2026-10-05
- Paragraphs 9, 14, 24 to 29 and the operative partCourt of Justice of the European Union, judgment of 26 September 2024, Case C-330/23, Verbraucherzentrale Baden-Württemberg v Aldi Süd - a reduction announced as a percentage or by a promotional statement must be determined on the prior price. Read 2026-10-05
- Art. 3(4)Directive 2005/29/EC, Unfair Commercial Practices Directive (consolidated text of 27 September 2026)Article 3, paragraph 4Click opens the article on EUR-Lex., Art. 6(1)(d)Directive 2005/29/EC, Unfair Commercial Practices Directive (consolidated text of 27 September 2026)Article 6, paragraph 1, point (d)Click opens the article on EUR-Lex.Directive 2005/29/EC (Unfair Commercial Practices Directive), Official Journal text of 11 June 2005 - Art. 3(4) on conflicts with specific rules and Art. 6(1)(d) on misleading information about a price advantage. Read 2026-10-05
- Art. 6(1), Art. 6(4)Regulation (EC) No 864/2007 (Rome II) - Art. 6 on the law applicable to unfair competition, which the Commission notice relies on for sellers outside the EU. Read 2026-10-05
- Art. 9(4)(g)Directive 98/6/EC, Price Indication Directive (consolidated text of 28 May 2022)Article 9, paragraph 4, point (g)Click opens the article on EUR-Lex. and (h), Annex, point 2Regulation (EU) 2017/2394 (Consumer Protection Cooperation Regulation), Official Journal text of 27 December 2017 - Art. 9(4) lists the minimum enforcement powers of the authorities and the Annex lists Directive 98/6/EC among the acts it covers. Read 2026-10-05
- § 11(1) to (4)Germany, Preisangabenverordnung (PAngV) § 11 - additional price indication on price reductions for goods. Read 2026-10-05
- § 4(1) to (3)Germany, Preisangabenverordnung (PAngV) § 4 - the unit price (Grundpreis) and its exceptions. Read 2026-10-05
- § 20 No. 1Germany, Preisangabenverordnung (PAngV) § 20 - administrative offences, including a breach of § 11(1). Read 2026-10-05
- § 3(1), § 3(2)Germany, Wirtschaftsstrafgesetz 1954 § 3 - breaches of price rules and the fine of up to EUR 25,000. Read 2026-10-05
- § 17(2), § 17(4)Germany, Gesetz ueber Ordnungswidrigkeiten (OWiG) § 17 - the amount of an administrative fine: negligence is fined at half the maximum, and the fine should exceed the gain from the breach. Read 2026-10-05
- Art. 5a, Article II; explanatory note 2.3 and 2.4Netherlands, Staatsblad 2022, 485 - decree of 30 November 2022 that inserts Art. 5a into the Besluit prijsaanduiding producten, in force from 1 January 2023, with its explanatory note. Read 2026-10-05
- National authority decision, NetherlandsNetherlands, Authority for Consumers and Markets (ACM) - fines of EUR 621,000 in total on five web shops for fake discounts, 2024. Read 2026-10-05
- National authority decision, NetherlandsNetherlands, Authority for Consumers and Markets (ACM) - the court confirms the fines on Leen Bakker and Koopjedeal, 13 November 2025. Read 2026-10-05
- Art. 17-bis(1) to (7)Italy, Decreto legislativo 6 settembre 2005, n. 206 (Codice del consumo), Art. 17-bis - price reduction announcements, inserted by Decreto legislativo 7 marzo 2023, n. 26. Read 2026-10-05
- Art. 22(3)Italy, Decreto legislativo 31 marzo 1998, n. 114, Art. 22 - sanctions; Art. 22(3) sets the fine that Art. 17-bis(7) of the Codice del consumo applies. Read 2026-10-05